Tuesday, September 15, 2026 · Mysuru
Subscribe
Star of Mysore - homeSTAR OF MYSORE
Mysuru's Evening Daily · Since 1978
Vol. XLVIII · No. 134 · Established 1978 · Founded by K.B. Ganapathy
Home/Editorial/Question of Quacks
Editorial

Question of Quacks

Despite the advances in methods and devices used in diagnosing and medically treating various illnesses along with expertise of the Physician with name and fame in society in general and among the…

By Author
Published August 13, 2019 · 2 min read
question of quacks

Despite the advances in methods and devices used in diagnosing and medically treating various illnesses along with expertise of the Physician with name and fame in society in general and among the regularly consulting patients in particular, sometimes one is advised to seek a second opinion from another practitioner of medical profession, also bestowed recognition in society. In that backdrop, one is prompted to cite the adage “No two watches agree” and its ironically sounding extension “If they agree, they are not watches.” Without meaning to treat the medical profession and its practitioners lightly, the analogy of the adage when applied to the healers would lead to the ridiculous expression that if two doctors agree (on the nature of illness and certainly on the line of medication), they may not be doctors (qualified or otherwise). The practitioners of medicine not qualified by passing the prescribed examinations and going through probation have come to be identified as quacks.

Relying on the advice of one Physician, similar to knowing the time by referring to one watch, is same as relying on information from only a single source. Further, just as a person with one watch can’t really be sure he knows the right time and has no way to identify error or uncertainty, the patient who doesn’t seek a second opinion is also unsure about the appropriateness of the treatment by his Physician. However, the note of caution is about the pitfall of having conflicting prescriptions. If one of the sources of prescription comes from a quack, the patient has no option but to say his prayers!

Continue reading

From the Editorial desk
photo
Editorial

Thank You

16 Feb 2026 · 2 min read
photo
Editorial

Thank You

16 Feb 2025 · 2 min read
photo
Editorial

Thank You

16 Feb 2024 · 2 min read